Wednesday, August 29, 2007

Embodiment, Identity and Presence in Second Life - New Wine or New Bottles?

Presentation by Magellan Egoyan (Geoffrey Edwards, Canada Research Chair in Cognitive Geomatics) at the CITASA mini-conference (Communication and Information Technologies section of the American Sociology Association) in Second Life on August 12, 2007, on the theme of "Web 2.0 and Beyond: The Sociological Significance of Virtual Worlds Supplanting Cyberspace"

Abstract : Nick Lee has written “our insistence on embodiment in virtual environments structures social interactions in these worlds in ways that we may not consciously be aware of…” (Lee, 2006). Identity has been defined as the set of strategies, beliefs, values and representations that are organized for the survival of the entity concerned (Dornic and Edwards, 2007). Presence has a variety of meanings, but here I am concerned with the sense of someone being present, even though their actual physical body may be absent. These three concepts are interdependent on each other, and each of them manifests within the world of Second Life. Within the field of education, a form of learning called “transformative learning” has gained interest. Ashe et al. (2005) have stated that “transformative learning involves a change in personal feelings, beliefs, and values known as meaning perspectives”. This concept of meaning perspectives, introduced by Mezirow in 1978, is very close to current definitions of identity. It is proposed that the concept of transformative learning provides a framework for understanding how our conceptualizations of the self, our bodies and our interaction with others are changed in Second Life. The process of transformation ensures that what emerges is, indeed, new wine not just “old wine in new bottles”. Within Second Life, identity is multiple, body is performative and presence is determined by the quality of our interactions with others. These ideas are illustrated by drawing on work with scientist and artist collaborators within Second Life.

Key words : embodiment, cognition, identity, transformation, learning, evaluation, health science, virtual worlds, Second Life

* * *


I’d like to begin by acknowledging the contributions from the team of scientists and students with whom I have been exchanging ideas and understanding over the past six weeks. The Embodied Research Group in Second Life that I coordinate is the source of many of the insights I’m going to be presenting. A group blog is in the process of being created, and will give form and flesh to most that I am going to say here, and much more.

Then I’d like to present to you a short video sequence I’ve prepared that gives some concrete examples of some issues raised by embodiment within Second Life. Let’s go and look at it now. It can be found on youTube... please click here to view its contents.



The video underlines the key idea about embodiment, that it is « performative » in nature. Here are a couple of definitions of embodiment – the first essentially cognitive, the second social. They both reinforce this idea that embodiment is less about physicality than it is about how we act and what our experience of and the consequences are of those actions – hence it is performative.



Here is a definition of « identity », a related concept, and also of « presence ». These three ideas are intertwined – if embodiment is the ground, identity is the figure, and presence is the frame by which we view the two in interaction (Figure 1).



Figure 1 : Embodiment, Presence and Identity are related concepts. This figure suggests one way of understanding this relationship



The video presented to you examples of the four ways in which embodiment is present in Second Life – through extension, through negociation, through affordances and through enablement. What is interesting about Second Life is that many experiences express more than one of these – indeed, often all four are involved. It may be one of the reasons why our bodily experience within Second Life can be so compelling at times.

The final expression of embodiment, as a form of enablement, underlines the fact that our experience of embodiment in virtual worlds can have a whole range of impacts on our identity and actions in so-called « real life ». This begins to open the idea that our experience of embodiment in Second Life, with its performative aspects and its ability to multiply our sense of identity, is transformative.

Another aspect of attempting to study these issues within virtual worlds such as Second Life is the complexity of scientific approaches and methodologies that could be used (Figure 2). In the Embodied Research Group, we have identified at least four scientific methodologies in use by different members of the group – behavioural experiments, a quantitative means of study ; conceptual design approaches ; computer simulation studies ; and qualitative research.


Figure 2 : The relationship between different methodologies for studying embodying issues, as described in the discussion below


No one person that I know of masters all four of these research methodologies – therefore, in order to address embodiment, identity and presence from all sides, we need to work together and pool our methodologies. Also, we may ask whether there is a framework that we could use to help bridge these different approaches and bring them together ?

The idea of experience within Second Life as transformative offers the seeds of an answer. A theory developed in education science and later refined in the health sciences, called « meaning perspectives », offers an interesting approach. According to Ashe et al., 2005, « transformative learning involves a change in personal feelings, beliefs, and values known as meaning perspectives ». Meaning perspectives were first introduced by Mezirow in 1978.

This approach is rooted in the Qualitative research paradigm, within the approach called « grounded theory ». The focus on transformative experience lends this method to an integration with methodologies of Conceptual Design, however. In addition, within health groups attempts are already being made to link this approach to behavioural studies. Finally, multi agent computer simulation methods exhibit emergent behaviours which may be associated with a transformation framework. Therefore, situating identity, embodiment and presence within Second Life in the context of transformative experience offers a global framework for developing a cogent scientific research program.

Finally, the transformative nature of the expression of embodiment, identity and presence within Second Life ensures that our experiences are not just « old wine in new bottles » … the different ways in which our identities are enabled in new ways holds out the perspective that we are seeing « new wine », at least some of the time.

These perspectives highlight the tremendous energy that researchers are feeling with regard to virtual worlds such as Second Life and their role in how we humans function. The field of research is opening up onto new vistas, making this a very, very exciting area of investigation.

References

  • Ashe, Brenda, Maurice Taylor and Claire-Jehanne Dubouloz, 2005, The process of change : Listening to transformation in meaning perspectives in adults in arthritis health education groups, Revue canadienne d’ergothérapie, Volume 72(5), 280-288.


  • Codol, J.P., and P. Tap, 1988, Revue internationale de psychologie sociale, no 2, cited by Lipiansky, Identité et communication.


  • Dornic, I., and G. Edwards, 2007, Le partage des émotions ou quand le corps part à la recherche des mémoires : des pistes de réflexion pour l’élaboration d’un outil destiné aux arts de la scène, submitted to L'Annuaire théâtral.


  • Lee, Nick, http://terranova.blogs.com/terra_nova/2006/08/the_prison_of_e.html


  • Lipiansky, Edmond-Marc, 1992, Identité et communication. L’expérience groupale, Paris, Presses universitaires de France.


  • Mezirow, J., 1978, Education for perspective transformation: Women’s re-entry programs in community colleges. Teacher's College, Columbia University, New York.


24 comments:

Unknown said...

Very informative post about "Embodiment, Identity and Presence in Second Life - New Wine or New Bottles?" Keep the nice job. We would love to see more, and I want to know if do you have knowledge about Dinero Online I need help with that

Ricardo Leiton said...

hello friend excellent post about Embodiment, Identity and Presence in Second Life - New Wine or New Bottles? I have a question and maybe you can help me, i need to know if I suffer of colon cancer can I take wine???

Izzy said...

Hello friend amazing and very interesting blog I really enjoyed reading and I would like to have any update about it and i want to know if you have any blog about health wellness

tianshasha said...

This is really a good article,I like it very much.


wow goldcheap wow goldwow

gold
buy wow goldwow gold
cheap wow goldbuy wow gold
World of Warcraft goldcheap World of Warcraft gold
World of Warcraft goldbuy World of Warcraft gold
World of Warcraft goldcheap World of Warcraft gold
buy World of Warcraft goldflyff

penya
cheap flyff penyaflyff penyabuy

flyff penya
flyff penyacheap

flyff penya
buy flyff penyaflyff

penya
flyff penyametin2 yangcheap metin2 yangmetin2

yang
buy metin2 yangmetin2 yangcheap flyff penya
buy metin2 yangmetin2 yangluna goldcheap luna gold
luna goldbuy luna

gold
luna goldcheap luna gold
buy luna goldluna goldluna gold

tianshasha said...

Really trustworthy blog. Please keep updating with great posts like this one. I have booked marked your site and am about to

email it to a few friends of mine that I know would enjoy reading..




lotro goldcheap lotro goldlotro goldbuy lotro goldlotro goldcheap lotro

gold
buy lotro goldlotro gold
lineage 2 adenacheap

lineage 2 adena
lineage 2 adenabuy lineage 2 adenalineage 2 adenacheap lineage 2

adena
buy lineage 2 adenalineage 2

adena
lineage 2 adenaaoc

gold
cheap aoc goldaoc goldbuy

aoc gold
aoc goldcheap aoc

gold
buy aoc goldaoc gold
aoc gold

cheap nfl jerseys said...

Such kind of articl is our need , it can give us help from different aspect for different people . after reading this article , I learn a mount of knowkedge increase my power , my families and I all like you article ,reading you article is our best love.
NFL jerseys
Puma Shoes
Ecco shoes
Nike Sneakers

pedro velasquez said...

Controlling a high-dimensional structure like a 3D humanoid skeleton isdominical costa rica tours a challenging task. Intuitive interfaces that allow non-experts to perform character animation with standard input devices would open up many possibilities. Therefore, we propose a novel multitouch interface for simultaneously controlling the many degrees of freedom of a human arm. We combine standard multitouch techniques and a morph map into a bimanual interface, and evaluate this interface in a three-layered user study with repeated interactions.
http://www.dominicalcostaricatours.com

Unknown said...

Nice post. I was checking continuously this blog and I am impressed! Very useful information specially the last part: ) I care for such info a lot. I was seeking this particular info for a long time. Thank you and good luck.Off The Plan Apartments Melbourne

Leonardo said...

Chronic Yeast Infection have been surfing online more than three hours today, yet Candida Overgrowth Symptoms never found any interesting article like yours. It’s pretty worth enough for me. In my opinion, if all webmasters and bloggers made good content as you did, the internet will be much more useful than ever before.

binturlu said...

miltenmaden kömür ve kömür çeşitleri ile içinizi ısıtacak.Miltenmaden kömür

Anonymous said...

You have a very good blog that the main thing a lot of interesting and useful!
buy drugs eye drop

film izle said...

Oyunlokali.com da okey oyna,101 oynatavla ,batak,ihale oyunları sizleri bekliyor.

Kyle Grando said...

Lovely stuff! If the information is implemented it can act as very beneficial and effective. Keep posting your updates..

Atrium Hotel Cincinnati

Op Dr Ali Mezdeği said...

Comments made ??about the issues impressed me. I like your site.
fue saç ekimi ne demek

Anonymous said...

A very nice page. I think the effort has passed, we have to thank you:))
Diş Doktoru

Anonymous said...

I want to thank you for this post. This information was very helpful.Please keep up the good work and I look forward to more of your great posts! tekken

Anonymous said...

nice blog :D :d tek parça film izle

Unknown said...

I have a social networking website and indian friends online community to get more friends to be reached our personal and official friendship.Jinekomasti

Unknown said...

Web Tasarımı

- New Wine or New Bottles?" Keep the nice job. We would love to see more, and I want to know if do you have knowledge a

jhoney said...

Thank you for your post, I look for such article along time, today i find it finally. this post give me lots of advise it is very useful for me.
diazepam purchase

jhoney said...

This is a nice post in an interesting line of content.Thanks for sharing this article, great way of bring this topic to discussion.
Buy 1 Million Facebook Likes

Unknown said...

The Open Source applications have surfaced as a better alternative to offer not just a time saving solution but also one that is cost effective and promises efficient results in the long run.
Online casino kaufen

jhoney said...

Thanks for a wonderful share. Your article has proved your hard work and experience you have got in this field. Brilliant .i love it reading.
where to buy stilnoct

Unknown said...

+2348108264684 men clinic penis enlargement herbal cream in Africa.This is the only Male Penis Enlargement Cream has been used by men around the world supplement that has been PROVEN to-enlarge your penis – safely, quickly, and importantly – PERMANENTLY.Full Oyama Penis Enlargement Cream when used will Increase in penis length by 1-5 inches Increase in penis width by 20%helps in preventing Premature Ejaculation.Achieved longer, rock hard erections All gains in penis length and width are 100% permanent Full Oyama Penis Enlargement Cream is also:100% Herbal, 100% Safest with no side effect and its of two types I have the one for enlargement and for reduction and your advised to use it by message 100% Satisfaction and Money Back Guarantee. DR. oyama, About my products i have herbal cream and oil 100% Permanent Guaranteed resulting it on your body where you feel you want to reduce or enlarge which will help you to be strong and you get the desirable size you want-within 3-5 days and when you get your desirable size you are advised to stop using it and the results you gain will remain permanent We also do deliveries all over Nigeria, and worldwide so i would like to know first when do you need the product.for more information call or whatsapp Dr.Oyama +2348108264684 email;droyamasolutiontemple@gmail.com